[Info] Critique of Vocals

Arena Magazine’s All Round Critique Of Idol Groups’ Lead Vocals

Tone Colour/ Timbre
1. Xiah Junsu (DBSK) - 12
2. Lee Hongki (FT Island), Jonghyun (SHINee) - 11
3. Ryeowook (SJ) - 9.5
4. Heo Youngsaeng (SS501) - 9
5. Sunye (WG) - 8
6. Taeyeon (SNSD) - 7.5
7. Daesung (BB) - 6.5

Performance Ability
1. Xiah Junsu - 12
2. Lee Hongki - 11
3. Taeyeon - 10.5
4. Jonghyun - 10
5. Sunye - 9.5
6. Ryeowook - 8.5
7. Heo Youngsaeng, Daesung - 7.5

Vocal Volume
1. Xiah Junsu - 12
2. Taeyeon - 11
3. Jonghyun - 10.5
4. Daesung, Sunye - 10
5. Lee Hongki - 8.5
6. Heo Youngsaeng - 8
7. Ryeowook - 7

Overall Package
1. Xiah Junsu - 12.5
2. Jonghyun - 11.5
3. Taeyeon, Sunye - 10
4. Lee Hongki - 9.5
5. Daesung - 8.5
6. Ryeowook, Heo Youngsaeng - 8

Total Score
1. Xiah Junsu - 48
2. Jonghyun - 43
3. Lee Hongki - 40
4. Taeyeon - 39
5. Sunye - 37.5
6. Heo Youngsaeng, Ryeowook, Daesung - 33

source: SNSD Baidu Bar + 闪耀星球 (smshinee.ifensi.com)
translated by: atlantis-x
credits: SHINee Forums